|
You have been with the company
two years. All your performance reviews have been excellent
and you have received two small promotions, with small salary
increases. You enjoy the people, you enjoy the work. However,
the small salary increases you have received so far are no
substitute for the substantial salary increase you need to
justify staying on board and working to the next level. How
do you approach your manager and the personnel director to
discuss with them a reasonable compensation package? We know
how; our Negotiation
Classes will teach you everything you need to know to
prepare for a successful salary negotiation. We will equip
you with negotiation skills to understand the strategies,
tactics and psychology of the negotiation process. Not only
will it help boost your salary, this negotiation
training will come in handy after your new promotion to
junior executive.
Regardless
of whether your investors' intentions are honorable, you can
make sure their letter of intent is.
When
you finally hear the magic words "We want to invest,"
temper your enthusiasm just a bit. That means nothing coming
from an investor's mouth until you successfully negotiate
the letter of intent.
The
letter of intent, or LOI, is the first official document
you receive from an investor after the handshakes are over
and the real work on the deal begins. Though 99 percent of
LOIs are not binding, don't underestimate the document's importance,
says Jay McEntee, an attorney and venture capitalist with
Harron Capital, a private venture capital firm located in
Frazer, Pennsylvania. "The letter of intent will serve
as the blueprint of the deal and moves negotiations from an
indication of interest to the closing table," says McEntee.
Most deals
die at the LOI stage because that is where you finally spell
out the precise terms and conditions of the investment. In
the lighter moments of making a presentation and accommodating
investors' due diligence, entrepreneurs often fail to discuss
the finer points of the deal with their potential investors.
When those details are spelled out in the letter of intent,
disagreements may surface. Many entrepreneurs are disappointed
when their deals go off track at the LOI stage, but the truth
is, the letter of intent is doing its job by preventing deals
that are doomed in the long term. On the other hand, if you
can get a signed letter of intent with an investor, the deal
will probably happen, and you're on your way to getting capital.
The letter
of intent is really a tool for your own protection and benefit,
so don't take it lightly. Here are some common errors entrepreneurs
make when creating letters of intent and how to avoid them.
1. Absence
of time frame: McEntee says entrepreneurs should avoid signing
letters of intent that do not have a specific time frame for
consummation—typically about 90 days—or a so-called
"drop dead" date by which the deal must be finished
and the company should have its capital. "When you combine
this with prohibitions against the entrepreneur seeking other
sources of capital—often in the letter of intent as
well—the result can be disastrous," says McEntee.
Specifically, entrepreneurs sometimes find themselves bound
by LOIs not to seek other financing deals, but, at the same
time, have little or no power to force a consummation or termination
of the deal in any sort of time frame. Thus, they not only
have no financing, but they also have no way of getting it
anywhere else.
For companies
that already have other sources of capital, letting investors
drag their feet may be uncomfortable but palatable. For an
emerging
company that is not yet bankable and has no other sources
of financing, however, a letter of intent that permits dithering
on the part of the investor can be a death knell. "Remember,"
says McEntee, "you do not want to put investors in a
position where they have an open-ended right to invest but
not any obligation."
2. Letting
the investor take over the hunt: Say you need $8 million,
and a venture capitalist agrees to put in $3 million but makes
the deal contingent upon syndicating the rest among other
investors he or she does business with. "Strategically,"
says McEntee, "it would be a mistake for an entrepreneur
to sign a letter of intent with these terms."
The mistake
is that you're staking your destiny on the venture capitalist's
ability to raise additional funds. "I would not want
to give up control to a third party," McEntee says. "Founders
and majority shareholders are most qualified, and most motivated,
to make sure a financing gets done." You should only
make an exception, he says, if the venture firm you're dealing
with happens to be a marquee name. Otherwise, if you receive
a letter of intent that says the investor will kick in $3
million contingent upon raising another, say, $5 million,
McEntee's advice is: "Do a deal for $3 million, and agree
to keep raising funds to get the other five. Just don't make
getting the other five a condition of the first $3 million."
3. Not
taking ratchet provisions into account: In neoclassical venture
investing, the investor and the entrepreneur both try to ensure
that each round of financing puts a higher value on the company
than the one before. However, LOIs often contain provisions
that put the onus on the entrepreneur if a later round is
done at a lower valuation. Specifically, says McEntee, "ratchet
provisions" mean that if the value of a company goes
down, the ownership stake of the VC goes up to
compensate for the loss they've experienced. Of course,
if their stake goes up, guess whose comes down?
"Ratchet
provisions will hurt you exponentially if you are unsophisticated
about them while negotiating the letter of intent," says
McEntee. "While eclining values may be a fact of life,
especially in [today's] market, taking 100 percent of the
hit is not. The best tactic is to make sure all shareholders,
VCs and founders take a weighted averages portion of the decline
in value, if there is one.
As you've
probably already guessed, you'll need legal counsel to get
you through an LOI. You and your lawyer may have several comments
to make on any letter you get from an investor. McEntee says
you can save time by having the attorneys hash out the easy
agreements. "At the end of the day, there may be one
or two major sticking points the entrepreneur and the investor
need to address as principals," he says.
"But
by all means," adds McEntee, "make sure your attorney
has experience. If not, they will dig in their heels on issues
they shouldn't. With all the deals I have on my desk, I'll
gravitate to the ones that can get done and stay away from
those where the other side is presenting
problems."
By David
R. Evanson & Art Beroff
Columbus

Negotiation Training - Always Negotiate with
Knowledge
Negotiation
Training
"Failure is the opportunity to begin again more intelligently."
Henry Ford
Suggested
Reading:
Negotiations
(Business Skills S.)
by Anne Laws
The
Art and Skill of Successful Negotiation
by John Ilich
Negotiation
(Couple Skills Audio Series)
by Matthew McKay
Soft
Power Skills, Women And Negotiations
by Ida Green
Negotiation:
Theories Strategies and Skills
by H. I. J. Spoelstra, W. D. Pienaar
A
lawyer's guide to effective negotiation
and mediation (Lawyering skills series)
by Paul Michael Lisnek
A
study of the relationship of negotiator skill and power as
determinants of negotiation outcome
by Chester Louis Karrass
Successful
Negotiation: Tips and Techniques to Improve Your Communication
Skills
by Robert B. Maddux
Negotiating
Skills for Managers
by Steven Cohen
Global
Business Negotiations: A Practical Guide
by Claude Cellich, Subhash Jain
|